Identifying Asian Magic Cards

This is the area where most Westerners have difficulty. But no, the three Asian languages are actually the easiest to distinguish! I came up with lots of tips for telling them apart, but there's one killer: the placement of the period. This will tell you right away. I'll show the text box for a "Stone Rain" as my example.

Chinese

The text:

Very regular, very complicated. Newer cards use a much bolder font. The period is a circle raised above the baseline of the text.

Japanese

The text:

The period is still a circle, but it's at the baseline of the text, like in English. Japanese also has several different kinds of characters, some like Chinese (kanji), some very simple and linear ones used for foreign words (katakana), and some very curly (hiragana). The hiragana (such as the last two characters in the above text) are very much unlike the Chinese and Korean characters.

Korean

The text:

In Korean, the period is just a dot. It's also the only of the three to put spaces between words. The characters are also quite distinctive, each one made up of simpler pieces.

Simplified versus Traditional Chinese

OK, this makes things tricky. Basically, there are two ways of writing Chinese: Traditional (used in Taiwan and Hong Kong), and Simplified (used in mainland China). Simplified Chinese cards have been in the limelight lately because they often have alternate artwork.

The main way to tell if you have a Simplified Chinese card or not is by the font. The text of the card is written in a brush-like font, whereas traditional Chinese cards use a constant-thickness, boxier font. Here's a comparison:

Simplified:
Traditional:

You can also look at the chart of card types, but this will only work for some card types and if you have a good eye for detail.

Update! Well, Wizards just wants to keep you guessing. Newer Chinese cards now have a round period on the bottom of the card, like Japanese. In addition, the new Simplified Chinese cards use the boxier font instead of the brush-style font. I'll have to scan some more examples some day...

Back to the main page...


Brett Allen (allen@cs.washington.edu)
This page is Copyright 2001-2006, Brett Allen.